May 8, 2025

Ag’s top content creators dish out biggest learnings

Building an audience as an ag content creator isn’t easy — imposter syndrome, overthinking, and “what if the puns flop?” are all part of the ride. But by learning from others in the space and hitting publish anyway, you can find your voice and grow real influence. These insights from seasoned ag creators offer simple, powerful reminders: start small, stay consistent, and always follow the energy.

One Original Idea: Ag Content Creator Knowledge Drop

‘Imposter syndrome’ ran deep in the early days of Magnetic Ag for me.

  • Who was I to start an ag newsletter… or dare I say, an ag media company?
  • Was I crazy to think this could fill a void and resonate with folks in the industry?
  • What if the puns fall flat?

The inner critic and self-doubter were working overtime.

But a small group of people (whether they knew it or not) inspired me to give it a shot.

Watching others build up niche audiences via interesting, original insights gave me hope that I could do something similar.

I reached out to several (but not all!) of those in my Ag Content Creator community to get their insights as many of you have shared your desire to pump up your content creation and audience-building for a personal brand or your company.

Here are the two questions I asked:

  1. What’s been the most valuable thing that happened for you professionally since building your audience?
  2. What’s a tip you’d give to someone (or a company) who is starting at square one to build an audience and create content?

Let’s just say that the responses were 🔥

So in order to let these words of wisdom really shine, I’m only going to share three responses today and will continue to share more over the course of the coming months.

There are lots of marketing and audience-building golden nuggets in these answers…

Go digging ⛏

From Janette Barnard of Prime Future:

Just start. Find a manageable cadence and hit publish, even when you feel all the nerves to hit publish and have more questions than answers. Just start.

From Tim Hammerich of the Future of Agriculture Podcast:

Try to be valuable to one person. There is plenty of content out there that tries to appeal to the broadest possible audience. One person who finds your content remarkable is far better than 1,000 who see it as generic. That one person will spread the word and give you something to build off of. Also – and this is cliche because it is true – consistency over time is the key. It’s also the hard part.

From Sarah Nolet of Tenacious Ventures + AgTech… So What? Podcast

There are so many reasons to not start building an audience, so the key is to systematically break these down. Here are a few common objections my brain throws at me, and how I have gotten around them.

→ Stuck defining a specific persona for your audience? Skip it and learn out loud, writing for yourself and sharing your hypotheses, reflections, and questions.

→ Worried about not being an expert? Use your personal experience to come from a place of credibility, as no one can question your expertise about what you’re thinking, feeling, or learning.

→ Don’t have the infrastructure set up properly? With two clicks on Twitter or LinkedIn you can hit publish and let the algorithms do the rest.

Ultimately, I’ve found that my best content comes from following my energy. If I feel like I’m really struggling for motivation, or only writing because I’m “checking the box,” it’s a strong indication that I need to switch topics. You’ll hate every minute of it if you don’t genuinely give a shit.


I told you these were 🔥, didn’t I?

Making our mark for clients in agribusiness, AgTech, ag lending, and brands serving rural America

At Pay Dirt Digital, we combine deep agricultural roots with digital innovation to help agribusinesses thrive.

Subscribe to Newsletter →